© 2006 All Rights Reserved. Do not distribute or repurpose this work without written permission from the copyright holder(s).
Printed from https://www.damninteresting.com/curio/the-singing-scourge/
Early in the 1200’s, Genghis Khan and the Mongol army he commanded were well on their way to becoming the most feared army in history. While many Khans before him had commanded large numbers of the fierce steppe warriors, never before had they been able to sustain a lengthy war against the cities that lay to the east and south of their home territory. Part of Genghis Khan’s unprecedented success came from his leadership abilities and charisma – no Mongol leader before him had managed to unite the disparate tribes into one cohesive unit – but another part came from his intense dedication to the practical.
Genghis Khan used his massive numbers of warriors effectively and sparingly. With a mix of lightning attacks and coordinated retreats, feints and propaganda, he achieved stunning victories over armies that seemed to have every advantage. But how did the Khan manage his tightly coordinated battle plans working with an army that was almost entirely illiterate? As anyone who has played the game of telephone knows, verbal directions tend to become garbled, and garbled orders can be fatal in a battle. An army with a complex plan needs messages to spread rapidly, and above all accurately. A message must remain the same whether it’s the first repetition, or the tenth, or the hundredth.
So what did the Khan do? He had his men sing.
Many armies sing, or chant, while on the move. It’s a common way to pass the tedium of lengthy days of traveling while helping groups of soldiers bond into tighter units. Singing may help marching men keep the same rhythm, or permit complaining that would never be allowed in conversation. However, Genghis Khan put the practice to a new, and more practical use. Every man in the Mongol army learned a fixed set of melodies. They sang them as they were on the move to ensure that the songs were solidly in their memories. Then, when battle came, the officers would compose their orders in rhyme and set them to one of the standard melodies. Remembering new orders became as easy as learning a new verse for an old and familiar song, and garbling them became much harder.
In addition, any soldier in the army could act as a messenger at need, as they all knew the requisite music. The method worked so well that eventually all the laws and rules of conduct for the Mongol army were set to music, so that each man could learn them, practicing them as they went.
Today singing is still a part of mnemonics, or the art of memory. The foundation of our cultural literacy is the alphabet, most commonly taught to children in the alphabet song. But after the alphabet, most of us stop, trusting our reading and writing skills to record information permenantly. Song is rarely used to impart information, and virtually never for messages. On the rare occasions when a song is used, such as “School House Rock”, the information imparted is static, not the dynamic message sending of the Mongols. Singing is, for the most part, entertainment and enjoyment only, not vital to our survival. But perhaps it would behoove us to remember that there is a more serious side to the pairing of music and words.
© 2006 All Rights Reserved. Do not distribute or repurpose this work without written permission from the copyright holder(s).
Printed from https://www.damninteresting.com/curio/the-singing-scourge/
Since you enjoyed our work enough to print it out, and read it clear to the end, would you consider donating a few dollars at https://www.damninteresting.com/donate ?
That is pretty damn ingenious.
You know, I have watched probably 6 or so documentaries and other shows (history channel and such) on the Mongol army and never have they mentioned this. Thanks for sharing this.
Very unique war strategy…if our society weren’t so distraced with their outward appearance then song could speed up education exponentialy.
That is amazing, and here i was singing the abc’s with my daughter not more than 10 minutes ago.
My cousins in Taiwan have three little daughters, and I remember something making a very strong impression on me while visiting Taiwan when the oldest daughter was 2 years old going on 3: she knew the entire multiplication table by heart at her tender age. She didn’t even know what multiplication meant, but she knew a clever little song she was taught by her parents that had the multiplication table as its lyrics. When she finally gets to second grade, that song she learned will be handy.
Too bad we don’t have songs for organic chemistry interacions and nomenclature. . .
There probably are songs for organic chemistry interactions, you might not be hanging around with the right crowd :-)
Michael Offutt sings some great chemistry songs, and I think there may be some about orgo as well. He has a song that I always sing when I remember Avagadro’s number: “six point oh two two times ten to the twenty-third…”
But that little mnemonic probably hasn’t changed the course of history likes Khan’s sung orders. Great post!
That’s just awesome. Imagine the look on their enemies’ faces when they realized they just got stomped on by a bunch of singers on horseback. And yeah, I’ve seen tons of documentaries about Genghis Khan, but never heard of this tactic…nice post.
What a brilliant idea! It’s one of those things that makes you ask, “Why didn’t I think of that?”
I can think of the impact that singing has on my memorization. My obviously is all the songs I have memorized from listening to over & over, though it’s not terribly practical. I’m a Christian, and I learned a silly “rap” song in Sunday school when I was a kid that was meant to helps us learn the books of the Bible. I still think back to it now and then to help me remember where to find Habakkuk and Nahum!
Perhaps the best example of this I can think of is the Christian parody band the ApologetiX. They are basically Weird Al Yankovic’s Christian-music counterparts. They take secular songs and give them Christian words. They will also reference Bible passages in their songs. It’s amazingly useful. For example, they have a parody of that 867-5349 song called “Genny 22” about Abraham almost sacrificing Isaac. If someone’s familiar with the song, it’s a snap to remember where to find that story in the Bible: Genesis 22.
If people can get over how corny it may seem at first, teaching things through song can prove extremely effective!
Interesting….. Now I’m wondering, just what lessons our children are learning from the present day Rap music? From the lyrics that I have heard, it’s not a good lesson.
Though I’ve never had cause to use it, thanks to Gordon Lightfoot I know all the great lakes.
Berkana – there’s at least one song out there about glucose (appropriately enough to the tune of Sugar, Sugar), that you can find if you search Google for ‘Singing Mnemonics’.
We used to filk popular songs for Organic Chemistry, though the density of information in them was pretty low. Mostly they were complaints set to music.
pretty damn interesting.
Marius said: “Though I’ve never had cause to use it, thanks to Gordon Lightfoot I know all the great lakes.”
LOL.
it’s actually quite a common technique in EFL:
http://litsite.alaska.edu/uaa/workbooks/jazzchants.html
Well, there’s always that professor at UC Davis who makes up parody lyrics about food safety and sings them to the tunes of popular songs.
http://foodsafe.ucdavis.edu/music.html
WARNING: This man’s singing is so bad it’ll violate your human rights. Listen at your own risk.
Good article.
Didn’t Morrissy say (or sing!) Sing Your Life?
Walk right up to the microphone And name All the things you love,
All the things that you loathe…
Don’t leave it all unsaid
Somewhere in the wasteland of your head…
I know my head was often a wasteland after an all-night cramming session! I should have sung!
Full lyrics to Sing Your Life:
http://www.oz.net/~moz/lyrics/killuncl/singyour.htm
Super article on a historic great.
Could the horde have been “steppe” warriors?
That is AWESOME.
I would love to get a hold of a translation of one of their songs and to hear a sample.
I think Khan’s army was defeated when his enemies illegally downloaded their music and then they knew what they were up to
I wonder if Genghis and the boys ever did Vegas? They’re certainly not as appealing as the 12 Girls Band. Actually I think their downfall started when some of their men were found to be lip synching.
Oh for Heaven’s sake! The Animaniacs had songs for States and their Capitals, the Countries of the World, th e Periodic Table of the Elements and much more! Check out this site:
http://www.stlyrics.com/songs/a/animaniacs8676/wakkosamerica295694.html
If you can hum “Turkey in the Straw” , you can learn all the state capitals in about two hours!
Great read. Good going Cynthia!
The technofreaks ain’t gonna like this one bit.
TDavis said: “Oh for Heaven’s sake! The Animaniacs had songs for States and their Capitals, the Countries of the World, th e Periodic Table of the Elements and much more! Check out this site:
http://www.stlyrics.com/songs/a/animaniacs8676/wakkosamerica295694.html
If you can hum “Turkey in the Straw” , you can learn all the state capitals in about two hours!”
I miss the Animamiacs!
sorry…I gotta say it – damn interesting. not a history buff but that was new to me!
I remember learning the quadratic formula in Algebra I Freshman year of high school to the tune of “Row, Row, Row Your Boat.”
“x equals the opposite of b, plus or minus square root! b squared minus 4ac, divided by 2a!” lol
I used to be a councilor for a public school run outdoor learning program for fifth graders. Oone of the program’s instructors used to make up silly raps and rhymes to help the kids remember things about nature, and he encouraged them to use his rhyme schemes to help them learn other things. While I was in Nursing school a few of my friends and I were studying and trying remember some concepts. We used this method, and got into trouble come test day because a few of us could be audibly heard humming, the test proctors thought it was an attempt at cheating. Once we explained it they deemed that it wasn’t but told us we weren’t ever allowed to to it again.
Though there were times where we continued to use this method to remember our studies at test time we made sure to not be heard.
Liked the article. Interesting stuff.
Especially the use of the word ‘behooved.’
>I deserve said: “If you can hum “Turkey in the Straw” , you can learn all the state capitals in about two hours!”
I miss the Animamiacs!”
When I was a kid I did not enjoy the Animaniacs. However watching them now I wish a clever educational show was on TV for kids (or more of them). Here are two awesome songs/video clips from the Anaimanicas. The Nations of the World is the video for the lyrics “I Deserve” submited.
All Presidents ——-
Nations of the World
I knew Mr. Ray from “Finding Nemo” was on to something with “OHHHH, Let’s name the zones, the zones the zones, let’s name the zones of the open sea!”
I also remember the Animaniacs cartoons, with their songs…gosh that was a great show.
I remember the Animaniacs singing songs about our states and capitals! I miss them too. I never memorized the song but in school they taught us a different song naming all of the 50 states in alphabetical order. In fact, I was just singing that song in my head today. I’ve always said that it was the most usefull song I ever had to learn in school.
They should tell this of Genghis Khan to kids in school before they teach them a song that will help them remember things, that way they know that it is actually a usefull tactic. :)
Personally, I thought the acme song was funny.
“Now, we write it backwards! e mc 2”
“you always make that A look like a 2”
FROM KITTY: COPY/DOWNLOAD TO DOSK / HARD-DRIVE
UNITED STATES ATTEMPTS TO BYPASS RECESSION (NEW EXPERIMENTS RELATED TO LOST RESEARCH OF TESLA / EINSTIEN / THE RADIOACTIVE BOYSCOUT
A new approach has been developed to EMPOWER the UNITED STATES/ avoid recession. This new method would EMPOWER AND PROTECT groups and individuals within the united states relating to Movie stars, singers, writers, scientists, meg-shift scientists, chemists,mathmetations, etc…. It has finally been concluded that by empowering these types of persons (within a country), you can empower the country as a whole. It has also been determined (as well), if these types of individuals were placed in a bad light, promoted with bad publicity (or even targeted), the country may be weakened (as a whole). Recent finding come from intellegence reports from or relating to David Charles Hahn (the radioactive Boyscout/ Meg-shift scientist). Recently, this individual has been placed in a bad light (definatly with the press). It has come to our attention that this individual has been attempting to strengthen the united states by locating anwsers for everything from finding “the fountain of youth” to “solving the world”s reactor fuel shortage problem” to “improving relationships” and even “comming up with ideas that may be able to “NOT ONLY” pull the United States out of it”s current recession but making this country “STRONGER THAN EVER”. In a recent interview with (David Hahn/ THE RADIOACTIVE BOYSCOUT), we asked David a few questions. David, what kinds of options do you think that the United States has for, pulling out of it”s current RECESSION? RESPONCE (David), I believe that the United States is currently accepting far to many foreign products and may not be exporting enough quality United States products. (David) I think that more United States companys and corporations should work together, more efficiently. In other words, there should be new clauses or laws developed that would have foreign companies actually (locate buyers for 2 to 5 times the amount/ in money). in other words, if a foreign company were about to accept payment in the form of U.S. currency, that foreign entity should have to locate buyers (located within any country in the world) for ,at least (twice the amount in U.S. dollars) that they would be receiving from the United States buyer. This would force (in reality just work a little harder) foreign companys or corporations to work for the United States (prior to receiving any United States currency). This would definatly increase the amount of products that the united States would ship over-seas and (IN TURN) create more American Jobs. (David), I strongly believe that the United states produces many (QUALITY MADE) products, right here in the United States. What do you currently think about the situation with (FORD MOTOR COMPANY)? I feel that too many people have lost thier jobs and homes, so far. (David), I believe that money should be (synergistically and multi-functionally) channeled into this great auto auto industry. I have a high degree of confidence that Ford Motor Company will produce “EVEN BETTER” and “HIGHER QUALITY” products, in the “NEAR FUTURE”. This should be a national “TEAM EFFORT” from government, military and civilian sources to “RE-BUILD” this great auto industry. (David) The (key words) here are “persistance’ and “trust”. (david) The auto industry has been running strong for many, many years. Some companies and corporations “take hard hit”s”. However, this does not mean that the company or corporation (in question) can not rebound and reclaim it”s position, at a much stronger level. (David) I believe that Ford just has to be one of these kinds of (industries) that can bounce back and bounce back (even stronger than before). Ford is definatly “one of the back bones of the state of Michigan”. We need to start channeling money and power to the proper places(company/corporation/industry/ etc…….. ….. …). David, what do you think of the current leaders within the united States? (David) I feel that this country has a “great many leaders” within this country, as a whole. I believe that our new “Chief and ommander” will be the “right choice” for moving this country into it”s best possible reality. I feel that his words are true and that he will stabilize and EMPOWER this country (especially during “hard times” like the current recession that we are in. (David) I strongly feel and believe that he is “the best man for the job”. *** There were a great deal of questions that followed after these responces. It appears that David intensions are of becoming a meg shift scientist (if he is not 1 already). David is a part of a great number of organizations and associations. Some of these that were confirmed were: Eagle Scout (Boy Scouts Of America), Former United States Navy, Former United States Marine Corps (RETIRED), American Legion Member, Time Travel Institute member, Associates Of Applied Science (Macomb Community College). 1 (UNCONFIRMED): Warlock (of the light)/ THE RADIOACTIVE BOYSCOUT etc…….. ….. …. At this point in time “we need people like David”. I personally feel that he is a cross between marie Curie (discovered radium) and Tesla (wireless energy).
Sincerely,
Kitty (REPORTING)!
So if I understand your garbled grammar correctly, you suggest that everyone who wants to sell a car to america has to acquire two other customers for an american car first?
Now if such a law were in effect, why would I want to sell a car to the USA in the first place? I would rather sell two cars to the people I’d have had to acquire to sell you one.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but the american automobile industry hasn’t been great for at least two decades. They missed out on developping new technologies and now they’re paying for that.
By the way, if your “genius” boyfried thinks he came up with the idea of his protectionist economy model by himself, you should point him to this wikipedia article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercantilism
It also contains a detailed explanation of why it won’t work.
“Lake Huron rolls, Superior gleams
In the rooms of her icewater mansion;
Old Michigan steams like a young man’s dreams
The islands and bays are for sportsmen;
And further below, Lake Ontario
Takes in what Lake Erie can send her;
And the ironboats go as the mariners all know
With the Gales of November remembered!”
Ah, elementary school music class, when I learned the lyrics of that entire song and sang them at the top of my terrible voice, to the great annoyance of all in the general vicinity.
My high school Latin teacher used this technique. It was probably very effective (I can still remember ” -i, -isti, -it, -imus, -istis, -erunt; -i, -isti, -it, -imus, -istis, -erunt; the perfect active indicative endings…”) but it made at least half the class groan loudly every time we knew we were going to be forced to not only listen but sing along.
Thumper325, you are a nut job and a pest, to put it mildly. I remember distinctly when you wrote about twelve pages’ worth of burble about how you were David Hahn, the Radioactive Boyscout, not just his interviewer.
As to the article itself, fascinating. I doubt it could ever work again, singing in a group now being fairly universally considered lame, childish, unmanly, and otherwise wholly unbefitting the military, but it’s still a wonderful idea.
Fascinating information that is new to me.
Big question for which I have not been able to find an answer: Why did Genghis Khan attack so many cities and other lands? Revenge? Greed? Mental aberration?
Pardon me while I go off to hum an aria.